Improved Support for Machine-assisted Ballot-level Audits
نویسندگان
چکیده
This paper studies how to provide support for ballot-level post-election audits. Informed by our work supporting pilots of these audits in several California counties, we identify gaps in current technology in tools for this task: we need better ways to count voted ballots (from scanned images) without access to scans of blank, unmarked ballots; and we need improvements to existing techniques that help them scale better to large, complex elections. We show how to meet these needs and use our system to successfully process ballots from 11 California counties, in support of the pilot audit program. Our new techniques yield order-of-magnitude speedups compared to the previous system, and enable us to successfully process some elections that would not have reasonably feasible without these techniques.
منابع مشابه
Operator-Assisted Tabulation of Optical Scan Ballots
Kai Wang discussed OpenCount (code.google.com/p/ opencount), an open-source software project to productively combine human cognition with machine functionality for the purpose of tabulating scans of paper ballots. The design was motivated by a need to go beyond what software can do to interpret interesting cases, such as poor markings and erasure marks. OpenCount interleaves computer vision tec...
متن کاملBRAVO: Ballot-polling Risk-limiting Audits to Verify Outcomes
Risk-limiting post-election audits guarantee a high probability of correcting incorrect electoral outcomes, regardless of why the outcomes are incorrect. Two types of risk-limiting post-election vote tabulation audits are comparison audits and ballot-polling audits. Comparison audits check some of the subtotals reported by the vote tabulation system, by hand-counting votes on the corresponding ...
متن کاملUnderstanding the Security Properties of Ballot-Based Verification Techniques (Short Paper)
As interest in the concept of verifiable elections has increased, so has interest in a variety of ballot-oriented mechanisms that offer the potential for more efficient verification than traditional precinctor machine-level audits. Unfortunately, threat analysis of these methods has lagged their design and in some cases implementation. This makes it difficult for policy makers to assess the mer...
متن کاملA Bayesian Method for Auditing Elections
We propose an approach to post-election auditing based on Bayesian principles, and give experimental evidence for its efficiency and effectiveness. We call such an audit a “Bayes audit”. It aims to control the probability of miscertification (certifying a wrong election outcome). The miscertification probability is computed using a Bayesian model based on information gathered by the audit so fa...
متن کاملScantegrity III: Automatic Trustworthy Receipts, Highlighting Over/Under Votes, and Full Voter Verifiability
Building on lessons learned from the November 2009 Scantegrity II election in Takoma Park, MD, we propose improvements to the Scantegrity II voting system that (1) automatically print trustworthy receipts for easier on-line verification, (2) highlight ballot features including over/under votes to comply with the Help America Vote Act, and (3) achieve full voter verifiability by eliminating prin...
متن کاملذخیره در منابع من
با ذخیره ی این منبع در منابع من، دسترسی به آن را برای استفاده های بعدی آسان تر کنید
عنوان ژورنال:
دوره شماره
صفحات -
تاریخ انتشار 2013